January 14, 2026

Orion Steel Exchange Review: Risks, Red Flags, and Due Diligence Tips

Investors don’t buy gold or silver because they’re dazzled by the metal. They buy because they’re worried about inflation, political risk, market volatility, or the reliability of their retirement accounts. That anxiety creates a fertile market for precious metals dealers, many of whom promise safety and steady hands. Orion Metal Exchange sits squarely in that ecosystem, courting both retail buyers and self-directed IRA investors. Done right, a precious metals allocation can add ballast to a portfolio. Done poorly, it can lock you into high markups, obscure storage arrangements, and tax headaches you didn’t expect.

This Orion Metal Exchange review focuses on the risks, the tells that something’s not quite right, and the practical steps to vet the firm and its competitors. Nothing here is intended as investment advice. It’s a field guide from someone who’s sat across from clients after they’ve signed the paperwork and wished they had asked a few more questions.

What Orion Metal Exchange Is — and Isn’t

Orion Metal Exchange is a precious metals dealer. That means it sells coins and bars, and it helps clients set up self-directed IRAs that hold IRS-approved bullion. It is not a custodian. It does not operate a depository. It is a middleman that coordinates with custodians and storage facilities, takes orders, collects payment, and arranges delivery to you or to a vault.

The distinction matters. In a traditional brokerage account, trade confirmations, custody, fees, and statements are consolidated under one brand. With metals dealers, functions are spread among several entities. A clean transaction depends on precise handoffs, accurate documentation, and clarity about who is charging which fee and why.

If you keep that basic structure in view, you can evaluate Orion like any other dealer: pricing transparency, inventory quality, IRA administration, storage logistics, and client support when things go sideways.

Pricing: Where Most of the Pain Hides

I’ve reviewed hundreds of purchase confirmations from metals dealers. The same pattern turns up again and again. The quote sounds competitive on the phone, the invoice looks fine, but only after the box arrives do buyers do the math against spot price and realize they paid a 15–35% premium for products they didn’t necessarily want.

The spread is not inherently bad. Dealers need to earn a margin, and certain coins command higher premiums because of minting costs or collector demand. The problem is opacity. The consumer rarely knows, at the moment of commitment, how much of the price reflects:

The live spot price for the underlying metal
The product premium for that specific coin or bar
The dealer markup

When you buy a 1 oz gold American Eagle, for example, you would expect to pay a premium over spot. In normal conditions, a fair all-in premium might land in the mid single digits to low double digits as a percentage, depending on market stress and order size. An obscure “semi-numismatic” coin might carry a higher premium, but that decision should be yours, not a salesperson’s. The fastest way to get overcharged is to mix IRA eligibility talk with pitches for collectible coins that are supposedly “rarer” or “more private.” The IRS doesn’t care about your coin’s romance; it cares if the product meets specific fineness and form rules.

If you ask Orion for a price breakdown and you cannot get a written quote that cleanly separates spot, product premium, and dealer markup, slow down. If you ask for a competitor match and the rep bristles or pivots to “value-added” features, assume the markup is paying for those features.

IRA Setup and Custodian Choice

Orion Metal Exchange, like most dealers, works with third-party IRA custodians. That relationship can be helpful, but it can also foster complacency. When a dealer acts as the guide, investors sometimes neglect to vet the custodian on its own merits. You should evaluate the custodian as though Orion didn’t exist: fees, turnaround times, reporting, and service quality.

Self-directed precious metals IRAs typically involve several fee layers. Expect a one-time setup fee, an annual administrative fee, and storage charges, usually tiered by account size. Reasonable annual all-in costs for a simple bullion IRA might land in the $150–$300 range for admin and storage together for smaller accounts, scaling up with value. If your paperwork lists “scaled benefits,” “program fees,” or vague “advantage” packages, clarify line by line. I’ve seen investors pay $500–$800 per year for what amounts to a PO box for coins.

Some custodians process transfers and purchase orders within 48–72 hours; others take a week or more. Delays matter in a volatile market. Ask Orion for the average interval from funds received to metals allocated at the depository. If the answer is “it depends,” ask for a range from real recent cases. If they won’t give one, call the custodian directly.

One more point that surfaces often: you can choose a different custodian than the one Orion suggests. The dealer may prefer a particular partner, but you are not obligated to accept that pairing. Sometimes a mismatch hides higher fees, slower service, or conflicts of interest that only show up later.

Storage: Commingled, Segregated, and What Your Contract Really Says

The word “segregated” means different things to different operators. In depository parlance, “segregated storage” usually means your metals are stored in a dedicated area, boxed or palletized with your name or account number, not mixed with other clients’ items. “Commingled” or “non-segregated” storage means you own a specific weight and type, but not the exact serialized bar you bought. Both models can be secure, but they carry different implications for future delivery and liquidation.

Where does Orion Metal Exchange land? As a dealer coordinating with third-party vaults, Orion will route your order to a depository arrangement the custodian supports. Ask for the depository’s name up front. Brinks, Delaware Depository, IDS, Loomis, and similar national facilities are common. Then ask for the storage type and the exact fee schedule. I’ve seen clients believe they had segregated storage because the salesperson used that word casually, only to learn the contract labeled it “commingled allocated.” That’s not fraudulent; it’s imprecise language meeting a rushed buyer.

Another storage detail: conversion and delivery mechanics. If you hold a precious metals IRA and you eventually want an in-kind distribution, how long does it take to move your coins from vault shelf to your doorstep? Which carrier will ship? What insurance limits apply per parcel? Investors discover insurance caps only after a package is split into multiple shipments, each below a threshold, extending delivery over a week instead of a day. Get those operational answers in writing before you buy, not during a frantic call with a tracking number in hand.

Shipping to Your Home: Title Transfer and Risk Windows

For non-IRA purchases shipped to your home, timing matters. At what moment does title pass? When the package leaves the dealer’s facility, or when you sign for it? What happens if a carrier scan shows “delivered,” but you never received it? Reputable dealers carry shipping insurance that covers loss until delivery. Reputable buyers follow delivery instructions precisely and inspect immediately.

Orion’s site and reps typically describe insured shipping, but “insured” needs contours. Insurance often excludes porch theft when the package is left without a signature. Some policies require an addressee signature specifically. If your workday makes signatures hard, arrange for a carrier hold at a staffed location or a local branch for pickup. Document everything, including the unboxing. It sounds fussy until you need the evidence.

Product Selection and the High-Premium Trap

A robust dealer carries standard IRA-eligible products: American Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, Australian Kangaroos, Austrian Philharmonics, and straightforward bars from recognizable refiners such as PAMP, Royal Canadian Mint, Perth Mint, or Valcambi. It’s fine if a dealer also offers historic coins or proofs, as long as those are clearly labeled and not blended into IRA conversations.

Where Orion Metal Exchange has drawn criticism — and it’s not alone — is when sales reps steer clients toward “limited mintage,” “collectible,” or “proof” coins under the guise of better privacy or liquidity. Those products can be beautiful and meaningful to collectors. They are not efficient exposures to the metal. The buy-sell spread is wider, and resale channels shrink when you go beyond mainstream bullion.

One investor I worked with brought in a statement showing $120,000 in IRA funds deployed into proof gold coins with an all-in markup north of 30%. Two years later, when gold had risen, the investor still couldn’t break even because the buyback offer reflected wholesale pricing for proof coins that dealers don’t want to inventory. If you’re tempted by a proof coin, fine, but treat it like art, not a commodity hedge.

Buyback Policies and Liquidity Reality

Most dealers advertise a buyback program. The phrase sounds comforting until you realize the buyback is not a contractual obligation. It’s an offer at the dealer’s discretion, at a price the dealer sets at that moment, subject to inventory and market conditions. The tighter the product’s market, the wider the spread.

Ask Orion for a sample buyback sheet for standard items. If spot silver is $25 per ounce, what is their bid for a 100 oz bar from a top refiner? If spot gold is $2,000, what is their bid for a 1 oz Eagle? The ratio of bid to spot, and the consistency of that ratio across several products, tells you how liquid your position will be in practice. If the rep says they can’t give firm numbers without seeing your order, ask for historical averages over the last month. Even ranges help.

When you sell from an IRA, the custodian must receive proceeds and account for them correctly. That administrative layer adds a few days. Make sure you understand who initiates the sale, how prices are locked, and how cash moves. Miscommunication here can leave you exposed to price swings you didn’t intend.

Advertising, Affiliations, and the Endorsement Problem

Metals dealers, Orion included, lean on endorsements: radio hosts, finance personalities, podcasts. These endorsements can make a firm feel established. They should not substitute for due diligence. Paid endorsements often come with scripts and talking points that highlight “economic uncertainty” and “diversification,” while skipping fees and spreads.

If a firm is pushing urgency — “limited availability,” “allocation closing,” “new policy changes” — set the pitch aside and do your homework. Physical metals aren’t perishable. Inventory cycles in weeks. If you’re told a price is “only good for 10 minutes,” you’re being nudged into a decision before you compare apples to apples.

Regulatory Landscape and Complaint Patterns

Precious metals dealers are subject to a patchwork of state and federal rules. They are not regulated like brokers or RIAs. That means you should check multiple sources to gauge a firm’s track record: state attorney general actions, the Better Business Bureau patterns, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission advisories for related scams, and consumer protection sites. When you search by company name, include the principal’s name as well. Sometimes enforcement actions follow individuals from one entity to the next.

I pay attention to complaint patterns, not isolated gripes. A single shipping delay in a pandemic surge is noise. A cluster of complaints about high-pressure upselling into collectible coins, refusal to disclose markups, or difficulty with buybacks signals a business model that benefits from confusion. If Orion has a mix of reviews, read the specifics. A well-run dealer will respond to complaints with timestamps, transaction details, and corrective steps. Vague corporate apologies don’t fix structural issues.

Taxes, Reporting, and the Things Sales Reps Gloss Over

Two tax points surface constantly with precious metals:

First, for IRAs: if you hold approved bullion in a self-directed IRA with a qualified custodian, you defer taxes as with any IRA. That’s the point. But “home storage IRAs” marketed as a way to keep your IRA metals in your safe almost always fail IRS scrutiny. The IRS does not recognize your closet as a qualified depository. If a rep hints you can bend that rule, step away. Disallowed constructs can trigger distribution treatment, penalties, and interest.

Second, for taxable accounts: when you sell physical gold or silver, gains are taxed as collectibles in the U.S., with a maximum federal rate that can be higher than the long-term capital gains rate on stocks. The dealer may issue Form 1099-B depending on the product and quantity thresholds. Make sure your CPA knows what you bought and sold, at what cost basis, and on what dates. Keep invoices. Keep shipping confirmations. Keep custodian statements. When the box of coins sits in a safe for years, paperwork tends to drift. You’ll want it when you sell.

Service Quality: The Difference Between a Smooth and Choppy Experience

Many investors judge a dealer on the sales call and the delivery. The subtler test is how the firm handles friction. A wrong bar sent. A payment that wires late from your bank. A custodian mismatch on SKUs. This is where firms either shine or unravel.

Speak to Orion about a hypothetical: you place an order, the custodian wires, and spot falls sharply before allocation. How do they handle price locks? Tell them you want to add an allocation two days later. Do they reprice the entire order or just the add-on? Ask who will be your point of contact after the sale. Sales associates often disappear once the commission posts. You want the post-sale desk number before you wire.

Common Red Flags to Watch for With Orion or Any Dealer

Use this as a short checklist when evaluating Orion Metal Exchange or its peers:

Vague or evasive answers when you ask for written, line-item pricing that separates spot, product premium, and dealer markup
Aggressive steering toward proof or collectible coins for an IRA without a clear rationale beyond “privacy,” “rarity,” or “better performance”
Pressure tactics tied to limited-time pricing, allocation countdowns, or regulatory scare talk
Mandatory pairing with a specific custodian without transparent comparison of fees and service levels
Buyback assurances framed as guarantees rather than best-effort policies with current bid quotes

Due Diligence Steps That Actually Work

Investors often ask for a perfect script. There isn’t one, but there is a rhythm that exposes hidden costs and weak processes. I’ve used variations of the following with good results.

Start with product discipline. Decide what you want before you get on the phone: for example, simple IRA-eligible bullion coins and bars only. If a rep tries to deviate, ask why, and write down the answer. Your notes will either contain a solid explanation or reveal salesmanship.

Request quotes in writing for three equivalent products from Orion and two competitors on the same day, ideally within an hour. For gold, use a 1 oz Eagle, a 1 oz Maple Leaf, and a 10 oz bar from a recognized refiner. For silver, a 1 oz Maple Leaf and a 100 oz bar. You don’t need to buy all three. You need price comparables that expose markups. Track spot during that hour to normalize. A reputable dealer will tolerate the scrutiny.

Call the suggested custodian yourself. Ask for the fee schedule, service times, and depository partners. Confirm storage type default (commingled vs segregated) and the exact annual cost at your projected account size. Have them email you their fee table. If Orion’s numbers conflict, ask why.

Review the purchase agreement and any IRA application before you sign. Look for arbitration clauses, venue restrictions, restocking fees, and delivery terms. If the contract includes a hefty “market loss” clause that applies even when the dealer delays allocation, that’s a problem.

Speak with the depository if allowed. Some won’t discuss account specifics, but they will verify that they work with your custodian and outline their storage options, insurance, delivery timelines, and per-parcel limits. You’ll learn whether what the dealer described matches the vault’s norm.

Document every conversation with names, dates, and promises. Good dealers don’t fear paper trails.

Where Orion Fits in the Competitive Landscape

The precious metals field is crowded. Some dealers compete on rock-bottom pricing and minimal handholding. Others emphasize white-glove service and a curated product list. Orion Metal Exchange positions itself closer to the full-service IRA segment, pairing sales support with custodian and storage arrangements.

That positioning is not inherently good or bad. It simply means you should weigh service promises against measurable costs. If Orion’s quotes land higher than a bare-bones competitor, are you getting tangible value? Faster allocation? Better post-sale support? Cleaner paperwork? If those intangibles are real and matter to you, a higher markup can be justified. If the “value” is soft — a glossy welcome kit and a hotline that goes to voicemail — move on.

I’ve seen Orion deliver as promised for straightforward bullion orders and IRA setups, and I’ve heard from buyers who felt nudged into pricier coins. That divergence often comes down to the individual rep. People make or break these experiences. Your job is to structure the process so a single persuasive voice can’t steer you away from your priorities.

Practical Scenarios and How to Handle Them

Suppose you want to roll $75,000 from a traditional IRA into a metals IRA with a 60/40 gold-silver mix. You call Orion and two competitors https://rebrand.ly/review/orion-metal-exchange on the same morning. You specify bullion-only, IRA-eligible products. Orion quotes you 1 oz Gold Eagles at spot plus a premium, 10 oz gold bars at a lower premium, and 1 oz Silver Maple Leafs. You ask for line items. Orion’s premiums are 2–3 percentage points higher than Dealer B on Eagles and comparable on bars. The custodian Orion prefers charges $200 annually, the one Dealer B uses charges $150. Orion promises allocation within 72 hours; Dealer B says five business days.

How do you decide? If you care about near-term allocation, you might accept a slight markup and a modestly higher annual fee. If you plan to hold five years or more, the recurring fee difference adds up; a slower allocation may not matter. If Orion pushes proofs “because the premium holds value,” you refuse and note the behavior. If they respect your framework and provide clean confirmations, they’ve earned a shot.

Another scenario: You have $20,000 for a taxable purchase to keep at home. Orion quotes 1 oz gold bars with a certain premium. A local coin shop offers lower premiums but can’t guarantee your preferred refiner. You value anonymity and immediacy. Buying locally for cash, with a competitive spread, might beat a mail-order dealer’s markup and shipping risk. Orion’s role in this case is less compelling unless their price lands close and they can ship insured to a secure pickup point. The best dealer changes with the situation.

Edge Cases: Returns, Substitutions, and Disputes

Returns on physical metals are rare and usually restricted to errors or defects. Once you lock a price and the dealer hedges, the market risk shifts. If you change your mind after a price lock, many dealers charge a market loss fee if the metal moved against them, plus restocking. Make sure you know Orion’s policy before you ever read your credit card number aloud.

Substitutions happen when specific SKUs are out of stock. If you accept substitutes, specify acceptable alternates in writing — for example, any LBMA- or COMEX-good delivery bar from a named list of refiners. Do not accept vague “similar items.”

Disputes should go first to the dealer’s compliance or customer care team, then to the custodian if it involves IRA assets, and finally to regulators if necessary. Keep the tone clinical. Facts and paperwork win these fights, not emotion.

A Balanced View: Who Might Be a Good Fit for Orion Metal Exchange

Orion Metal Exchange may suit an investor who values handholding through an IRA setup, wants a conventional roster of bullion products, and is comfortable paying slightly higher premiums for a coordinated experience — provided the rep respects boundaries and provides transparent pricing. It’s less suitable for a buyer hunting for the lowest possible spread, a collector chasing specific numismatic pieces with independent grading priorities, or an investor seeking to self-direct every vendor relationship.

The deciding factor is your discipline during the sales process. If you set terms — bullion-only, written quotes, custodian choice, documented fees — and Orion meets them without friction, your risk of unpleasant surprises falls dramatically. If the call veers into urgency and sizzle, hang up and regroup.

Final Due Diligence Tips Before You Wire

Demand written, line-item quotes that separate spot, product premium, and dealer markup for the exact SKU and quantity.
Verify custodian and depository fees directly with those entities; do not rely solely on a dealer’s summary sheet.
Insist on bullion-only if that is your goal, and decline proofs or collectibles unless you want them for non-investment reasons.
Ask for current buyback bids on the same products you’re buying, and get them in writing as ranges tied to spot.
Read every contract clause that mentions arbitration, market loss, restocking, delivery terms, and storage type; clarify ambiguities in writing.

The precious metals market rewards patience and clarity. Whether you choose Orion Metal Exchange or another firm, your outcomes will hinge less on perfect timing and more on how well you pin down the dull details: fees, storage, liquidity, and documentation. Do that, and the gold or silver you buy will behave like the hedge you intended — not an expensive souvenir of a rushed decision.

Gold IRA Rollover Requirements Blog