Upgrade Your Home with Simple Improvements

August 26, 2025

Do I Really Need A Whole House Water Filtration System?

Boerne water has personality. Some days it tastes sharp and metallic, other days it leaves spots on shower glass and a chalky ring in the kettle. Well water in the Hill Country can smell like rotten eggs after a heavy rain. City water varies by neighborhood and season. So the real question is less “Do I need a filter?” and more “What is in my water, and what do I want to protect?” Whole house water treatment systems can solve real problems, but the right answer depends on your home, your plumbing, and your goals.

This article walks through what Gottfried Plumbing llc sees daily in Boerne, Fair Oaks Ranch, Kendall Woods, Menger Springs, and the backroads near Sisterdale. It explains common water issues, system types, what they actually remove, and where homeowners overspend. It also shows how to make a smart decision based on test results, rather than guesswork or a door-to-door pitch.

What Boerne Homeowners Are Dealing With

Hard water is the default across Boerne and the Texas Hill Country. Groundwater picks up calcium and magnesium as it moves through limestone. On a test strip, many homes read 15–25 grains per gallon, which counts as very hard. That hardness leaves scale on fixtures, burns through tank water heaters, and clogs tankless heat exchangers. It also uses up soap and makes laundry scratchy.

City water in Boerne meets state standards, but it can carry chlorine and chloramine for disinfection. Those disinfectants protect public health and keep bacteria at bay in the distribution lines, yet they can give water a pool-like odor and taste. Sensitive skin often reacts to chlorinated showers. Rubber gaskets in fixtures age faster in heavily chlorinated water.

Well water adds its own twists. Many private wells around Boerne show iron, manganese, and hydrogen sulfide. Iron stains tubs orange. Manganese can turn grout gray-brown. Hydrogen sulfide causes that sulfur or rotten egg smell, more noticeable after plumbing sits unused. A few wells test positive for coliform bacteria. Seasonal storms and low aquifer levels can change water chemistry overnight, which can make last year’s filter a poor fit this year.

Add in sediment from new construction or main line repairs, and it is easy to see why whole house water treatment systems have become a common upgrade, right alongside tankless heaters and recirculation pumps.

What “Whole House” Actually Means

A whole house water filtration system treats water at the point of entry. The equipment sits near the main shutoff and water meter or, on well properties, near the pressure tank. Every tap, shower, appliance, and outdoor spigot downstream receives the treated water. This is different from a single faucet filter or a refrigerator cartridge.

There are three main categories that cover most needs in Boerne:

  • Filtration: media or cartridges that remove sediment, chlorine, chloramine, and some chemicals. Think sediment filters, carbon beds, catalytic carbon, and specialty media.
  • Conditioning: equipment that changes how minerals behave. Traditional softeners swap hardness minerals for sodium or potassium. Template-assisted crystallization, or TAC, keeps minerals from sticking without adding salt.
  • Disinfection: systems that kill or disable microbes. UV lights are common on wells. In rare cases, peroxide injection and contact tanks handle stubborn odors.

Homes often pair these in a train. For example, a well system might run sediment first, then carbon for odor, then a softener, then UV. A city home might run a backwashing carbon filter for taste and odor and a softener after it to control scale. The order matters because each step protects the next.

What Problems Do These Systems Solve?

Start with the end result a homeowner wants. Most clients mention at least one of these goals:

Better taste and odor. A whole home carbon filter removes chlorine and many odor compounds, so coffee tastes clean and showers smell neutral. It also reduces chloramine when a catalytic carbon media is used.

Scale control. Softeners stop calcium and magnesium from bonding inside pipes, water heaters, and fixtures. Homeowners see fewer spots on glass and longer water heater life. Tankless water heaters in Boerne often need descaling at least annually without a softener; with a softener, descaling can stretch to every 24–36 months, sometimes longer, depending on use and hardness level.

Stain and odor removal on wells. An iron filter pulls iron and manganese out before they stain tubs and sinks. If hydrogen sulfide causes smell, catalytic carbon paired with air-injection or peroxide can correct it. UV disinfection protects against bacteria without adding chemicals.

Basic protection for appliances and plumbing. Sediment filters catch sand and grit that would otherwise scratch valve seats or clog dishwasher and refrigerator lines. In older homes around downtown Boerne, this can prevent drippy faucets and leaking toilet fill valves.

Cases Where A Whole House System Is A Strong Yes

There are signs that point clearly to a full-home solution. If two or more apply, a whole house system pays for itself in fewer service calls and longer appliance life.

  • White, crusty buildup on faucets, shower heads, and around the kitchen sink that returns quickly after cleaning.
  • Frequent tankless heater descaling or a tank heater that dies in under 8 years.
  • Rotten egg or metallic smell that worsens after the water sits overnight.
  • Orange or brown stains in tubs, toilets, or on laundry.
  • Dry, itchy skin after showers and more soap needed to get a lather.

In these homes, a point-of-use filter at the kitchen sink will not help the shower, the dishwasher, or the water heater. Treating at the entry fixes the root cause everywhere.

Cases Where A Whole House System Might Be Overkill

Some homes in Boerne test moderate for hardness and complain only of taste at the kitchen sink. In those cases, a high-capacity under-sink carbon block with a dedicated faucet solves the drinking and cooking side at a lower price. Or a refrigerator with a good built-in filter may be enough for taste concerns.

Another edge case shows up in properties that water the garden heavily. If the goal is soft showers and scale-free glass, but there is no need to soften a hose bib that feeds landscaping, a plumber can bypass outdoor spigots. That keeps salt use and wastewater lower on softener setups and cuts costs over time.

City Water vs. Well Water in Boerne

City water clients often ask for two things: get rid of chlorine and tame hardness. A common setup is a whole house backwashing carbon filter followed by a softener or a salt-free conditioner if they prefer low maintenance. Carbon units on city water can run 5–10 years before media replacement, depending on water use and chlorine levels. Backwashing keeps the bed fresh and prevents channeling.

Well water is more custom. Gottfried Plumbing llc tests for hardness, pH, iron, manganese, sulfur, and total coliform. A typical well stack might be a spin-down sediment prefilter, an iron and sulfur system using air-injected catalytic media, then a softener, then UV. If the well sometimes pumps sand after storms, the spin-down filter catches it and is easy to rinse without tools. UV bulbs need annual replacement and should sit after carbon and softening so the lamp sees clear water for reliable disinfection.

Softener or Salt-Free Conditioner?

Softeners remove hardness minerals with ion exchange. They add a small amount of sodium to the water. In Boerne’s 20 gpg water, a glass of softened water adds about the sodium of a slice of bread. Most people find that acceptable, but low-sodium diets may prefer a potassium setup or a salt-free conditioner.

Salt-free systems use media that changes how minerals crystallize so they do not stick to pipes and heaters. They reduce scale buildup but do not make water feel “soft.” Soap will not lather as easily as with a softener. For homeowners who care most about protecting a tankless heater and avoiding spots, a well-sized salt-free conditioner can work. For those who want silky showers and the lowest maintenance on fixtures, a true softener wins.

On city water that carries chloramine, the carbon stage in front of a salt-free system is essential. Chloramine can wear out the media early. The same is true for well water with iron. Iron should be removed before any conditioner or softener, or it will foul the resin or media.

What About Reverse Osmosis?

Reverse osmosis is a great point-of-use solution for drinking and cooking. It removes dissolved solids, including sodium from a softener. In Boerne, many homeowners run RO at the kitchen sink and fridge while using whole house carbon and softening for the rest of the home. Whole home RO exists, but it wastes water and needs large storage tanks, booster pumps, and careful plumbing. It makes sense only for specific medical or industrial needs. For most houses, RO belongs under the sink, not at the main.

Cost, Maintenance, and Lifespan

Prices vary by size and media quality, but local ranges help frame decisions. A good whole house carbon system for a three-bath home in Boerne often lands between $1,500 and $2,800 installed. A softener sized for 20 gpg hardness and a family of four typically falls between $2,000 and $3,500 installed, depending on valve quality and resin. Iron and sulfur systems add $2,000 to $4,000 based on chemistry and flow rate. UV disinfection runs $900 to $1,800 installed, plus about $100–$200 per year for bulbs and cleaning.

Media life depends on water use and contaminants. Backwashing carbon lasts 5–10 years. Softener resin can last 8–12 years on city water and 5–8 years on well water if iron is present. Salt or potassium use depends on hardness and water use. Many Boerne families refill a standard brine tank every 6–10 weeks. Air-injected iron filters need occasional maintenance on the air valve and a media change every 5–8 years. UV lamps should be replaced annually, and quartz sleeves cleaned during that visit.

Gottfried Plumbing llc suggests a yearly check to test water, confirm settings, clean injectors, and verify bypasses. That visit takes 30–60 minutes and catches small issues before they cause service calls.

Sizing Matters More Than Brand

A common mistake is buying a system built for one bath and running it on a four-bath home. Undersized systems channel, fail to backwash correctly, and lose performance fast. Correct size is set by peak flow rate and daily water use, not just the number of bedrooms.

For example, a home in Trails of Herff Ranch with three full baths, a soaker tub, and a tankless heater can hit 12–14 gallons per minute when two showers and the washing machine run together. A 10-inch carbon tank will starve flow and leave chlorine breakthrough. A 13-inch or 14-inch tank with a 1.5 to 2.0 cubic foot media bed can handle the flow and still backwash well on Boerne’s water pressure.

Softener sizing uses hardness level, number of people, and desired regeneration frequency. A family of five at 20 gpg hardness will overload a small 32,000-grain unit and force it to regenerate too often, wasting salt and water. A 48,000–64,000 grain system often fits better and runs more efficiently.

What A Good Installation Looks Like

Neat plumbing with clear bypass valves. A labeled layout makes service simple and prevents surprises. Gottfried Plumbing llc installs full-port isolation valves and a proper bypass so homeowners can water the yard with untreated water if they choose.

Drainage and discharge that meet code. Softeners regenerate to a drain. The line needs an air gap. On septic systems near Fair Oaks Ranch, the drain route should protect the tank. If the site lacks drainage, a dry well or sump pump plan may be needed.

Power and protection. Control valves and UV systems need a standard outlet. Surge protection prevents control head failures during summer storms.

Freeze-ready in exposed garages. Many Boerne homes place equipment in garages that can dip below freezing. Insulation, drain-friendly unions, and a freeze plan keep lines safe during the rare cold snaps that have hit the Hill Country in recent years.

Common Myths Gottfried Technicians Hear

“Softened water is slippery because it leaves soap behind.” The slick feel comes from soap reacting differently without hard minerals. It rinses clean, and skin often feels less dry over time.

“Salt-free systems remove hardness.” They do not remove minerals. They keep them from sticking. Glass may still show light spots, but they wipe off easier.

“City water is safe, so I do not need filtration.” Safety and comfort are separate. Disinfectants protect public health. Carbon protects taste, odor, and plumbing parts inside the home.

“Filters take out healthy minerals.” Carbon filtration does not strip minerals. Softeners swap hardness minerals for sodium or potassium but leave calcium and magnesium in very low dissolved form. For mineral-rich drinking water, a dedicated RO with a remineralization cartridge can strike the taste balance you prefer.

A Simple Way To Decide

Here is a short, practical path that homeowners in Boerne can use. It works for both city and well properties and avoids expensive guesswork.

  • Test the water at the tap and at a hose bib. Check hardness, iron, pH, chlorine or chloramine, and sulfur odor. Gottfried Plumbing llc can run in-home tests and send lab samples if needed.
  • Walk the house. Look at shower glass, fixtures, toilets, and the water heater isolation valves. Check the dishwasher and washing machine hoses for scale.
  • Pick the smallest system that solves the actual problem. If the goal is taste only, consider carbon at the sink or a whole house carbon filter. If scale is ruining equipment, add softening or conditioning. On wells with odor and staining, plan a full train from sediment to iron/sulfur to softening and UV.
  • Size for peak flow. Make sure the equipment can handle two showers and a wash cycle at once without losing performance.
  • Plan for maintenance. Choose media and valves with parts available in the Boerne area and schedule a quick annual service.

Real-World Examples From Boerne Homes

A family near Menger Springs had two tankless units that needed descaling every 8–10 months. The home tested at 22 gpg hardness with chloramine present. A backwashing catalytic carbon filter and a properly sized softener cut the scale load. Two years later, the descaling interval moved to about 24 months, and glass spots dropped to occasional.

A well property off Scenic Loop had 3 ppm iron and clear sulfur odor. The owners had already tried a big-box store filter that clogged monthly and failed to stop staining. After testing, Gottfried Plumbing llc installed a spin-down sediment prefilter, an air-injected iron and sulfur system with catalytic media, a softener, and a UV light. Laundry stains disappeared in a week, and the rotten egg smell stopped on day one.

A small garden home near Boerne Lake wanted better coffee and chlorine-free showers but preferred low upkeep. A whole house carbon system with automatic backwash solved taste and odor with no salt to refill. The owners added a compact RO under the sink for ice and cooking. Maintenance is now a quick annual visit to refresh the RO filters and verify the carbon backwash schedule.

Water Treatment And Your Plumbing System

Quality water protects valves, cartridges, and heater exchangers. In hard-water Boerne homes without treatment, cartridge faucets can start dripping within 18–24 months. Shower mixing valves can gum up and stick, and tankless heaters throw error codes as scale builds in the heat exchanger. Whole house water treatment systems often pay back through fewer service calls: fewer cartridge replacements, longer heater life, and less time scrubbing glass.

There is also a hidden gain in water pressure. Scale narrows pipes and clogs aerators. After softening, many homeowners notice a steadier shower stream and quieter toilets. Over time, softened water dissolves some existing scale, especially in newer PEX and copper lines, which helps restore flow.

Environmental Questions Homeowners Ask

Softeners regenerate and discharge brine. The volume is tied to hardness and system size. A correctly set softener uses less salt and water treatment installation Boerne TX water during regeneration than a poorly sized one. On septic systems, it helps to bypass irrigation and hose bibs and to choose efficient resin and metered control valves. For those who want to avoid brine discharge, a salt-free conditioner paired with whole house carbon is an option, with the understanding that feel and spot control differ from a softener.

Backwashing carbon uses water to rinse the media bed. Programming it for the right frequency and time prevents waste. Seasonal adjustments, especially after heavy rains or in drought periods, keep systems efficient.

UV disinfection adds no chemicals but uses power and requires clean water upstream. A well-designed train keeps energy use modest and performance reliable.

How Gottfried Plumbing llc Approaches It

The team starts with a test, not a pitch. They measure hardness, disinfectants, iron, pH, and sulfur odor at minimum. On wells, they can pull a sample for a lab to confirm bacteria. Then they design the smallest setup that hits the stated goals: taste, scale control, odor removal, or all three. They install cleanly with labeled valves and a clear bypass. Homeowners get a simple maintenance sheet with salt estimates, bulb dates for UV, and backwash schedules coded to local water pressure.

Most jobs finish in half a day. Larger well systems can run a full day, especially if drainage or electrical needs a tidy upgrade. Gottfried Plumbing llc stands behind parts that are easy to service in Boerne, with valves and media available locally.

So, Do You Really Need One?

If water leaves spots everywhere, heaters scale up, or well water smells and stains, a whole house system is practical, cost-effective protection. If the only complaint is flat coffee, a focused solution at the sink may be enough. The right answer starts with a test, a look at how the home uses water, and a simple plan that avoids overbuying.

If you live in Boerne, Fair Oaks Ranch, or nearby Hill Country neighborhoods and want clear advice and clean water, schedule a quick water test with Gottfried Plumbing llc. The team will measure what matters, explain trade-offs in plain language, and set up a system that fits how the home actually runs. Clean water, fewer repairs, and less scrubbing is a phone call away.

Gottfried Plumbing LLC provides plumbing services for homes and businesses in Boerne, TX. Our licensed plumbers handle water heater repair, drain cleaning, leak detection, and emergency service calls. We are available 24/7 to respond to urgent plumbing issues with reliable solutions. With years of local experience, we deliver work focused on quality and customer satisfaction. From small household repairs to full commercial plumbing projects, Gottfried Plumbing LLC is ready to serve the Boerne community.

Gottfried Plumbing LLC

Boerne, TX, USA

Phone: (830) 331-2055

Website: